Reports until 13:56, Sunday 08 December 2024
H1 SUS
oli.patane@LIGO.ORG - posted 13:56, Sunday 08 December 2024 - last comment - 19:29, Monday 09 December 2024(81668)
Suspension watchdog trips during the large earthquake

Back in March (76269) Jeff and I had updated all the suspension watchdogs (besides OFIS, OPOS, and HXDS since those were already up to date) to use better blrms filtering and to be output into um. We set the suspension watchdog thresholds to values between 100 and 300 µm, but these values were set arbitrarily since there was no way to previously see how far the stages move during different scenarios. We had upped a few of the thresholds after having some suspensions trip when they probably shouldn't have, and this is a continuation of that.
During the large earthquake that hit us on December 5th, 2024 18:46 UTC, all ISI watchdogs tripped as well as some of the stages on several suspensions. After a cursory look, all suspensions that tripped only had either the bottom or bottom+penultimate stage trip, meaning that with the exception of the single suspensions, the others' M1 stage damping should have stayed on.

We wanted to go through and check whether the trips may have just been because of the movement from the ISIs tripping. If that is the case, we want to raise the suspension watchdog thresholds for those stages so that these suspensions don't trip every single time their ISI trips, especially if the amount that they are moving is still not very large.

Suspension stages that tripped:

Triples:
- MC3 M3
- PR3 M2, M3
- SRM M2, M3
- SR2 M2, M3

Singles:
- IM1 M1
- OFI M1
- TMSX M1

MC3 (M3) (ndscope1)

When the earthquake hit and we lost lock, all stages were moving due to the earthquake, but once HAM2 ISI tripped 5 seconds after the lockloss, the rate at which the OSEMs were moving quickly accelerated, so the excess motion looks to mainly be due to the ISI trip (ndscope2).

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 86 150 (unchanged)
M2 150 136 175
M3 150 159 200

 

PR3 (M2, M3) (ndscope3)

Looks to be the same issue as with MC3.

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 72 150 (unchanged)
M2 150 162 200
M3 150 151 200

 

SRM (M2, M3) (ndscope4)

Once again, the OSEMs are moving after the lockloss due to the earthquake, but the rate they were moving at greatly increased once HAM5 saturated and the ISI watchdogs tripped.

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 84 150 (unchanged)
M2 150 165 200
M3 150 174 225

 

 SR2 (M2, M3) (ndscope5)

Again, the OSEMs are moving after the lockloss due to the earthquake, but the rate they were moving at greatly increased once HAM4 saturated and the ISI watchdogs tripped.

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 102 150 (unchanged)
M2 150 182 225
M3 150 171 225

 

IM1 (M1) (ndscope6)

Again, the OSEMs are moving after the lockloss due to the earthquake, but the rate they were moving at greatly increased once HAM2 saturated and the ISI watchdogs tripped.

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 175 225

 

OFI (M1) (ndscope7)

Again, the OSEMs are moving after the lockloss due to the earthquake, but the rate they were moving at greatly increased once HAM5 saturated and the ISI watchdogs tripped.

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 209 250

 

TMSX (M1) (ndscope8)

This one seems a bit questionable - it looks like some of the OSEMs were already moving quite a bit before the ISI tripped, and there isn't as much of a clear place where they started moving more once the ISI had tripped(ndscope9). I will still be raising the suspension trip threshold for this one just because it doesn't need to be raised very much and is within a reasonable range.

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 100 185 225
Images attached to this report
Comments related to this report
oli.patane@LIGO.ORG - 19:09, Sunday 08 December 2024 (81686)

We just had an earthquake come through and trip some of the ISIs, including HAM2, and with that tripped IM2(ndscope1). I checked to see if the movement in IM2 was caused by the ISI trip and sure enough it was (ndscope2). I will be raising the suspension watchdog threshold for IM2 up to 200.

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 152 200
Images attached to this comment
oli.patane@LIGO.ORG - 22:45, Sunday 08 December 2024 (81691)
Images attached to this comment
oli.patane@LIGO.ORG - 19:29, Monday 09 December 2024 (81716)

Yet another earthquake!. The earthquake that hit us December 9th 23:10 UTC  tripped almost all of our ISIs, and we had three suspension stages trip as well, so here's another round of trying to figure out if they tripped because of the earthquake or because of the ISI trips. The three suspensions that tripped are different from the ones I had updated the thresholds for earlier in this alog.

I will not be making these changes right now since that would knock us out of Observing, but the next time we are down I will make the changes to the watchdog thresholds for these three suspensions.

Suspension stages that tripped:

- MC2 M3

- PRM M3

- PR2 M3

MC2 (M3) (ndscope1)

It's hard to tell for this one what the cause for M3 tripping was(ndscope2), but I will up the threshold here for M3 anyways since I'm sure even if the trip was directly caused by the earthquake, the ISI tripping definitely wouldn't have helped!

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 88 150 (unchanged)
M2 150 133 175
M3 150 163 200

 

PRM (M3) (ndscope3)

This one it's pretty clear that it was because of the ISI tripping(ndscope4).

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 44 150 (unchanged)
M2 150 122 175
M3 150 153 200

 

PR2 (M3) (ndscope5)

Again this one it's pretty clear that it was because of the ISI tripping(ndscope6).

Stage Original WD threshold Max BLRMS reached after lockloss New WD threshold
M1 150 108 150 (unchanged)
M2 150 129 175
M3 150 158 200
Images attached to this comment