Search criteria
Section: H1
Task: FMP
We've had short locks today, and the veritcal osems suggest that the test masses are at an extreme not seen since last Febuary. Eric noted that he had to change settings for the air handler 82763
We've had very short locks today, Jim has reverted his change from just over a week ago although we don't think that's likely to be the problem.
Perhaps one of our optics is rubbing.
I ran the rubbing script using 2 DOWN times, 1 from today (1423423402) and 1 from earlier this week (1423098322).
I put the images together to make it easier to look through.
All the OPLEV sums have been dropping over the past ~2 days, except for SR3, PR3 sees the largest drop but that's expected from all the spot moves?
There was only 4 seconds of down time in the first time from this rubbing script,1423423402 . We probably need to sit in down for the whole duration of the script (I'm not sure how much data it gets).
Yesterday 4-2-2024 the HVAC pre-filters at each of the 4 out station buildings along the arms were replaced with new pre-filters. The new pre filters are the same size (24"x24"x2") and filtration level (MERV-13) as the old pre-filters that were taken out. During inspection of the pre-filters an inspection was done on the "Main Filter Cartridge" which is the harder, more permanent, deeper, and heavier duty material type cartridge. It's installed in front of the pre-filter that is used for air filtration in the HVAC system. These are nearing the end of their life cycle. These will likely be replaced in the coming couple months.
(Randy, Mitchell, Betsy)
The West Bay cleanroom work is complete so the large cleanroom has been turned off again. Room turned off ~9:30am this morning.
(The 4x 3IFO QUAD upper structures have now been moved to their smaller storage containers, relabeled , and ICS records re-organized. The large ISI storage container that they came out of still houses the 2 Elliptical baffle down tube assemblies and partial TMS telescope subassemblies. Photo pictures have been also added to the containers for our future selves.)
Over the course of the day today, Ryan and I have noticed the BNS inspiral range dropping starting around noon PST. Since it's mostly come back at this point almost 12 hours later, it seems to be correlated to a drop in LVEA temperature which in turn has raised the large corner station optics (BS and ITMs) according to their vertical top-mass OSEMs (see one- and six- day trends attached). Perhaps the HVAC system lowered the heat into the LVEA in response to the outside temperature rising? Since H1 has remained locked and observing over this time, I imagine the angular control loops have been keeping up with alignment changes, but possibly altering noise in DARM which has been affecting range. I don't believe any action is needed here, but I think it's still worth noting here how corner station temperature changes can affect our observation performance.
TITLE: 11/28 Day Shift: 16:00-00:00 UTC (08:00-16:00 PST), all times posted in UTC
STATE of H1: Preventive Maintenance
INCOMING OPERATOR: Ryan S
SHIFT SUMMARY:
LOG:
Start Time | System | Name | Location | Lazer_Haz | Task | Time End |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
16:04 | FAC | Kim and Karen | EX, EY | N | Technical cleaning | 17:23 |
16:07 | SUS | Randy, Chris, Mitchell | EY, EX | N | EX cleanroom sock install | 18:32 |
16:08 | VAC | Jordan | MY, EY | N | Turbo pump tests | 17:01 |
16:11 | FAC | Cindi | FCES | N | Technical cleaning | 17:14 |
16:15 | VAC | Gerardo and Jordan | FCES | N | Valve install | 17:15 |
16:48 | CDS | Fernando and Marc | LVEA | N | SQZ 4 Beckhoff modifications | 19:44 |
16:55 | SQZ/CDS | Fil | CER/SQZ Racks | N | Pulling cables | 19:51 |
17:13 | Richard | LVEA | N | Electrical walkthrough/escorting people | 17:43 | |
17:14 | FAC | Cindi | Mech room | N | Cardboard collection | 17:44 |
17:43 | VAC | Ken and Gerardo | FCTE | N | Valve install | 20:13 |
17:49 | VAC | Travis | EX | N | Turbo Station Cooling Lines Upgrade | 20:15 |
17:50 | VAC | Jordan | MY, EY | N | Turbo pump tests | 18:46 |
18:00 | FAC | Karen and Cindi | LVEA | N | Technical cleaning + High bay check | 19:29 |
18:10 | VAC | Norco | CP8 EX | N | LN2 Fill | 20:05 |
18:13 | FAC | Ken | LVEA | N | Electrical work | 20:07 |
18:19 | Richard | M-Station/Wandering/FCES | N | Smoke detector check | 19:56 | |
18:47 | CDS | Erik | N | IOC Server Reboot (and temp change) | 18:57 | |
18:51 | VAC | Jordan | FCTE | N | Valve install assistance | 19:51 |
19:02 | TCS | Camilla | LVEA | N | TCS Setup | 20:11 |
19:22 | FAC | Karen | Recieving | N | Bringing car out | 19:54 |
19:28 | FAC | Eric | CER/Sup | N | Investigating temperature excursion | 19:51 |
19:45 | CDS | Fernando | N | Rebooting with modifications | 19:56 | |
19:48 | FAC | Mitchell and Eric | CER | N | Checking CER disconnects | 20:15 |
20:04 | CDS | Jonathan | N | DAQ Restart | 20:23 | |
20:06 | VAC | Travis | EX | N | Sensor correction correction | 20:17 |
20:14 | VAC | Gerardo | FCTE | N | Valve Opening | 20:24 |
Tyler "has recently changed the chiller pumps to not be on at all times and come on when needed. He gave me some data for when the EX chiller has been turning on and off over the last 2.5 weeks" (TJ, 2023). I took this data and plotted it against our range as well as the average internal temperature at EX to see if we would lose range when the chiller at EX turned on(attachment1).
Over this date range, the longest amount of time that the chiller was on consistently was for just over two hours. With both these longer segments and the more regular shorter segments of 'on' time (sometimes just 10 minutes on), there is no noticeable change in the range when the chiller turns on or off. There are multiple times where the range trends downward after the chiller starts turning on for longer stretches of time (red attachment2), but it is not consistent - yellow(attachment3) and green(attachment4) rectangles show the range rising with chiller 'on' times. Therefore I am inclined to attribute the lowering of the range during these times as being due to changes in indoor/outdoor temperatures and wind and not the chiller.
Tagging Facilities as well.
Thank you for getting these out Oli, this is great! I agree with you that it doesn't seem like this chiller pump has any direct impact on our range, though perhaps we might want to consider looking further into a possible correlation of VEA temps and our range.
Clarification: It is not the chiller "pump" that was reconfigured to run only when demanded. It was the chiller themselves. It's also not clear that this was the status quo for all chillers across site. It was only recently discovered on one chiller in particular. The chiller "pump" has always and will continue to run regardless of the state of the chiller itself as glycol needs to be continually cycled through the AHU cooling coils at all times.
All looks nominal for the site HVAC fans (did catch a transition between fans at MY for this one). Closing FAMIS 26251.
State of H1: Lock Acquisition
Winds have died down enough to the point where I'm attempting to lock H1. So far so good; there was one lockloss while trying to lock DRMI, but this time currently up to ENGAGE_ASC_FOR_FULL_IFO.
Also, the RO_WATER alarm has been going off/on for the past 3 hours. Let Bubba know, also tagging facilities.
At 9:45am local time Chiller 1 at End Y went into alarm for "Evaporator Water Flow Lost". When I arrived at the EY chiller yard I observed that neither chiller was running but chilled water pump 1 was continuing to run. I noted the alarm and headed for the mezzanine above the AHU's to asses what the supply and return pressures were nearest the evaporator coil. Immediately I read 0 (or what I thought was 0) at the return line. This would generally indicate that there has been enough glycol loss within the system that makeup is necessary via the local tank (though I've never seen it get to 0). Until I read that both supply lines were at an alarming 140psi (normal operating pressures for all 4 supply and return float around 30). I immediately phoned Richard to have him command the chilled water pump 1 off to stop the oversupply of chilled water. For reasons not clear to me the disable command via FMCS Compass was not taken at the pump. I went back to the chiller yard and observed that 1: the pump had not been disabled and 2: pressures at the pump were at around 100psi (normal operating for the current frequency is about 50). Following that, I manually threw the pump off at the VFD to prevent further runaway of the system. Between the time of noting 140psi and manually throwing the pump off, the system pressure increased to 160psi. After a thorough walk-down of the system, I elected not to utilize our designed redundancy in chiller 2 and chilled water pump 2 as I was still unaware what was causing the massive overpressure at all supply and return lines. It was also found that the return line was not actually at 0, but instead had made a full rotation and was pegged on the backside of the needle (all of these need replacement now). Macdonald-Miller was called on site to help asses what the issue might be. Given that there was recent incursions to flow via R. Schofield the strainer was the primary point of concern. We flushed the strainer briefly at the valve and noted a large amount of debris. after a second flush, much less/next to none was noted. This alleviated the system pressure substantially. The exact cause of the fault and huge increase of pressure is still not clear. There are a number of flow switches at the chiller. Bryan with Mac-Miller suspects part of the issue may live there, and we are going to pursue this further during our next maintenance window. Work was also performed at the strainer within the chiller where rubber/latex-esque debris was found. Work on Chiller 1 to continue but for now the system and end station is happy on chiller2/CHWP2. Looking at the FMCS screen shows temp's have normalized as of the writing of this log. T. Guidry B. Haithcox. R. Thompson C. Soike R. McCarthy
J. Kissel, for T. Guidry, R. McCarthy Just wanted to get a clear separate aLOG in regarding what Corey mentioned in passing in his mid-shift status LHO:72423: The EY HVAC Air Handler's chilled water pump 1 of 2 failed this morning 2023-08-25 at 9:45a PDT, and thus the EY HVAC system has been shut down for repair at 17:35 UTC (10:35 PDT). The YVEA temperature is therefore rising as it equilibrates with the outdoor temperature; thus far from 64 deg F to 67 deg F. Tyler, Richard, and an HVAC contractor are on it, actively repairing the system, and I'm sure we'll get a full debrief later. Note -- we did not stop our OBSERVATION INTENT until 2h 40m hours later 2023-08-25 20:18 UTC (13:18 PDT), when we've gone out to do some commissioning.
The work that they've been doing so far today to diagnose this issue has been in the 'mechanical room'. Their work should not add any additional significant noise over what aready occurs in that room at all times, so I do not expect that there should be any data quality issues as a result of this work. But, we shall see (as Jeff points out) if there are any issues from the temperature itself changing.
They are done for the weekend and temperatures are returning to normal values.
Chiller Pump #2 is the chiller we are now running.
Chiller Pump #1 will need to be looked at some more (Tyler mentioned the contractor will return on Tues).
Attached is a look at the last 4+yrs and both EY chillers (1 = ON & 0 = OFF).
See Tyler's LHO:72444 for more accurate and precise description of what had happened to the HVAC system.
Following up on TJ's alog from 8/17 (72293), it was noted that a garbage truck at LSB was quite loud. The seismometers in the LVEA clearly picked up the noise, and it seems to coincide with noise in DARM. It's hard to be certain with only one signal, but it probably warrants further investigation.
Spectrogams attached of one seismometer and DARM for 2 minute time span around when noise was reported:
-Of signal
-Zoomed in with boxes on noise regions
-Stacked with some boxes around correlated noise
Oli relayed to Genevieve that the garbage truck left at 16:05:00 local time yesterday (8/24). No noise was reported on site, but approximately 2 minutes before the truck left we see a signal in the LVEA seismometers similar to that from the truck last week, and the signal once again shows up in DARM.
Genevieve, Lance, Robert
To further understand the roughly 10Mpc lost to the HVAC (https://alog.ligo-wa.caltech.edu/aLOG/index.php?callRep=72308), we made several focussed shutdowns today. These manipulations were made during observing (with times recorded) because such HVAC changes happen automatically during observing and also, we were reducing noise rather than increasing it. The times of these manipulations are given below.
One early outcome is that the peak at 52 Hz in DARM is produced by the chilled water pump at EX (see figure). We went out and looked to see if the vibration isolation was shorted, it was not, though there are design flaws (the water pipes arent isolated). We switched from CHWP-2 to CHWP-1 to see if the particular pump was extra noisy. CHWP-1 produced a similar peak in DARM at its own frequency. The peak in accelerometers is also similar in amplitude to the one from the water pump at EY. One possibility is that the coupling at EX is greater because of the undamped cryobaffle at EX.
Friday HVAC shutdowns; all times Aug. 18 UTC
15:26 CS SF1, 2, 3, 4 off
15:30:30 CS SF5 and 6 off
15:36 CS SF5 and 6 on
15:40 CS SF1, 2, 3, 4 back on
16:02 EY AH2 (only fan on) shut down
16:10 EY AH2 on
16:20 EY AH2 off
16:28 EY AH2 on
16:45 EY AH2 and chiller off
16:56:30 EY AH2 and chiller on
17:19:30 EX chiller only off, pump stays on
17:27 EXwater pump CHWP-2 goes off
17:32: EX CHWP-2 back on chiller back on right after
19:34:38 EX chiller off, CHWP-2 pump stays on for a while
19:45 EX chiller back on
20:20 EX started switch from chiller 2 to chiller 1 - slow going
21:00 EX Finally switched
21:03 EX Switched back to original, chiller 1 to chiller 2
Turning Roberts reference to LHO:72308 into a hyperlink for ease of navigation. Check out LHO:72297 for a bigger picture representation of how the 52 Hz peak in the broader DARM sensitivity, and from the Time Stamps in Elenna's plots, they were taken at 15:27 UTC, just after the corner station (CS) "SFs 1, 2, 3, 4" are off. SF stands for "Supply Fans" i.e. those air handler unit (AHU) fans that push the cool air in to the LVEA. Recall, there are two fans per air handler unit, for the two air handler units (AHU1 and AHU2) that feed the LVEA in the corner station. The channels that you can use to track the corner station's LVEA HVAC system are outlined more in LHO:70284, but in short, you can check the status of the supply fans via the channels H0:FMC-CS_LVA_AH_AIRFLOW_1 Supply Fan (SF) 1 H0:FMC-CS_LVA_AH_AIRFLOW_2 Supply Fan (SF) 2 H0:FMC-CS_LVA_AH_AIRFLOW_3 Supply Fan (SF) 3 H0:FMC-CS_LVA_AH_AIRFLOW_4 Supply Fan (SF) 4
My Bad: -- Elenna's aLOG is showing the sensitivity on 2023-Aug-17, and the Robert logging of times listed above are for 2023-Aug-18. Elenna's demonstration is during Robert's site-wide HVAC shut down 2023-Aug-17 -- see LHO:72308 (i.e. not just the corner as I'd errantly claimed above.).
For these 2023-Aug-18 times mentioned in this LHO aLOG 72331, check out the subsequent analysis of impact in LHO:72778.
Lance, Genevieve, Robert
PEM injections
We are redoing part of the formal PEM injection program, which took place for a week before the run, because the 75-60W change reduced vibration coupling by factors of 2 or 3. On Wednesday, during the commissioning slot, we finished acoustic injections at EY and started shaker injections at EY. Thursday we finished the main shaker injections at EY.
ETMY bias sweep with electronic ground injections
Fig. 1 shows that the ETMY bias setting that minimizes our electronic ground injection coupling has possibly changed a little, but not much, since January.
HVAC shutdown
I shut down the HVAC, site-wide, from about 15:23 to 15:37 Aug 17 UTC. The range increased by a little less than 10 Mpc to a little over 160 Mpc. Elenna posted a spectrum for the best part of the site-wide shutdown (see below). The shutdown and especially the re-start took time, so Fig. 2 shows just the effect of of the chilled water system at EX. Also, we shut down SF4 only (the fan pushing 11,000 CFM at the CS, from 21:18 to 21:32 UTC, but we did not see an improvement in range. We will continue with a focussed study tommorrow in order to better understand the locations of the problems.
For the ASD of GDS-CALIB_STRAIN of Elenna's that Robert mentions comparing the HVAC ON vs. OFF times see LHO:72297.
Robert did an HVAC off test. Here is a comparison of GDS CALIB STRAIN NOLINES from earlier on in this lock and during the test. I picked both times off the range plot from a time with no glitches.
Improvement from removal of 120 Hz jitter peak, apparent reduction of 52 Hz peak, and broadband noise reduction at low frequency (scatter noise?).
I have attached a second plot showing the low frequency (1-10 Hz) spectrum of OMC DCPD SUM, showing no appreciable change in the low frequency portion of DARM from this test.
Reminders from the summary pages as to why we got so much BNS range improvement from removing the 52 Hz and 120 Hz features shown in Elenna's ASD comparison. Pulled from https://ldas-jobs.ligo-wa.caltech.edu/~detchar/summary/day/20230817/lock/range/. Range integrand shows ~15 and ~5 MPC/rtHz reduction at the 52 and 120 Hz features. BNS range time series shows brief ~15 MPC improvement at 15:30 UTC during Robert's HVAC OFF tests.
Here is a spectrum of the MICH, PRCL, and SRCL error signals at the time of this test. The most visible change is the reduction of the 120 Hz jitter peak also seen in DARM. There might be some reduction in noisy peaks around 10-40 Hz in the signals, but the effect is small enough it would be useful to repeat this test to see if we can trust that improvement.
Note: the spectra have strange shapes, I think related to some whitening or calibration effect that I haven't bothered to think about to make these plots. I know we have properly calibrated versions of the LSC spectra somewhere, but I am not sure where. For now these serve as a relative comparison.
According to Robert's follow-up / debrief aLOG (LHO:72331) and the time-stamps in the bottom left corner of Elenna's DTT plots, she's is using the time 2023-08-17 15:27 UTC, and that corresponds to the time when Robert had turned off all four the supply fans (SF1, SF2, SF3, and SF4) in the corner station (CS) air handler units (AHU) 1 and 2 that supply the LVEA around 2023-08-17 15:26 UTC.